71
General Discussions / Re: Impact on Child Support, when Payee is going out of JOB
« Last post by Guru on May 02, 2017, 11:12:05 PM »Firstly, it sounds like the HO granted your request for reduced child support - a win for you. Attorneys don't like losing to a pro se, so they will probably run you through the ringer a little.
I'm uncertain what you mean by "challenge." A HO decision can be appealed to a district court judge simply to review the use of discretion and the evidence at hand. I don't find this to be an open ticket for tons of more discovery. It sounds as if this attorney is trying to pull a fast one and get themselves a bunch more evidence.
From what I know, an appeal is not an opportunity to restart the case and get all new evidence in hopes of a better decision. It is merely a review of what the judge or HO had at the time to make the decision and look for procedural errors. So, I would be inclined to remit a letter to the attorney that this is an appeal and as such you do not feel compelled to provide new evidence.
The reason the attorney wants all this stuff is they are on a fishing expedition to catch you in some kind of lie or loop hole. I would attend the appeal with all the same evidence you had and argue that for civil cases it is your understanding that is not a retrial. If the judge wants to set your case for evidentiary hearing, he may do so, but then you could provide all that info (and request exactly the same of the other party).
I'm uncertain what you mean by "challenge." A HO decision can be appealed to a district court judge simply to review the use of discretion and the evidence at hand. I don't find this to be an open ticket for tons of more discovery. It sounds as if this attorney is trying to pull a fast one and get themselves a bunch more evidence.
From what I know, an appeal is not an opportunity to restart the case and get all new evidence in hopes of a better decision. It is merely a review of what the judge or HO had at the time to make the decision and look for procedural errors. So, I would be inclined to remit a letter to the attorney that this is an appeal and as such you do not feel compelled to provide new evidence.
The reason the attorney wants all this stuff is they are on a fishing expedition to catch you in some kind of lie or loop hole. I would attend the appeal with all the same evidence you had and argue that for civil cases it is your understanding that is not a retrial. If the judge wants to set your case for evidentiary hearing, he may do so, but then you could provide all that info (and request exactly the same of the other party).

Recent Posts